DoorDash vs UberEats vs Grubhub? Which one wins?

A long-time food delivery driver compares the three! 

So you've been looking into the food delivery game but don't know where to start? What to expect? 

Can't decide which app is best for your needs? Maybe DoorDash? No wait, maybe UberEats is better. What about Grubhub?

Which one pays more? I hear UberEats. Nah, keep reading!

No need for confusion. I've done them all and will give you a breakdown of each here so you can decide which one (or two) best fit(s) your needs.

A little about me: I've been a gig economist for a few years now. I've done over 4,300+ (this number keeps changing obviously) orders across platforms, starting with Instacart and DoorDash and over a year ago, UberEats and Grubhub. I'm also signed on to deliver for Amazon Flex but have been waiting to do a delivery at my local Whole Foods. That market is pretty cornered by long-time drivers but I digress.

Please be aware that I've updated this page with current screenshots so you have the latest info but things change and I try to keep everything updated. See something that's wrong? Contact me!

If you already know you want to do Instacart, check here for how to get started as an Instacart Shopper. However, if you are going to do Instacart, I do recommend you have one of the apps below as backup as well so keep reading.

I do recommend you give this article a read for more in-depth information about how each compares. 

Just a quick reminder: you have to be flexible if you want to do this long-term. If you're just doing it for the summer or as a small side hustle, it's not as important to have a backup but since you're going through the signup process anyways, why not sign up for two?

There are constantly fluctuations based on demand so it's good to have at least one backup and not put all your eggs in one basket. 

Without further ado, I give you the side by side comparison of DoorDash, UberEats and Grubhub. 

---

Signup process

DoorDash signup

---

Grubhub signup

---

UberEats signup

What happens after signup? 

Once your background check clears and you sign your delivery partner agreement (similar process across apps), you'll be able to upload your picture to the app (DoorDash does not require a picture, which I kind of like) and enter your bank account info.

Speaking of ...

Bank verification

In terms of bank info, DoorDash and UberEats let you add a bank account for weekly transfers (which are free) AND a debit card for when you need to cash out daily (for a fee). DoorDash now has a DasherDirect debit card you can sign up for to circumvent the cash out fee. I'll link to my pros and cons page about DasherDirect at the end of this page.

Grubhub just has one account that both the weekly transfers and cash outs go into.

DoorDash used to take two weeks (and still does as I'm writing this) before you get paid the first time, which I know is a major deal breaker for many people who need money right away. 

DoorDash also has the highest cash out fee at $ 1.99, compared to UberEats, which is increasing to $1.25 and Grubhub at 50 cents per cashout. 

UberEats allows you to cash out the moment you earn money and Grubhub has a three-day bank info verification window before it allows you to cash out your earnings when you first start. After that, you can cash out your earnings the same day for a $1.25 cent fee on UberEats and 50 cents on Grubhub. Like I said, DoorDash charges $1.99

So while DoorDash wins for ease of signup, overall, UberEats wins for ability to get your cash right away with Grubhub coming in second. 

Let's talk gear

I know some of you wonder if you need any gear before hitting the road and I would like to say yes you will need an insulated bag on your first day because your job is to deliver food ... and most of that food is intended to stay hot from the time you pick it up to the time you deliver.

You can check out my quick essential gear video here.

---

---

Good gear, bad gear, no gear

Grubhub gear

Grubhub sends you a package within the first few days including a pretty substantial insulated bag (it even fits pizza boxes!), their debit card (more on that later but it's not really all that relevant) and a sign saying “delivery in progress”. This may have changed since DoorDash stopped sending their bag so maybe Grubhub stopped doing that as well. I'm pretty sure it still sends a bag though, maybe not the delivery in progress sign.

Grubhub is serious about the delivery game! Again, these things change so you may receive different things since it's been a while since I signed up.

UberEats gear

UberEats doesn't send you sh*t.

UberEats does not even require an insulated bag, it barely suggests you get one, which I personally find to be quite unfair to the customer because UberEats is also terrible about grouping long distance orders so I do not see how customers ever get their food hot and on time.

Some orders on UberEats have three customers (UberEats has gone back and forth on that but I saw one as recent as April 2024 so it's still an occasional thing) so that third customer is gonna get some pretty cold food by the time you deliver.

You do get to request their debit card for retail orders, which arrives quickly. More on that in a minute.

Grubhub definitely wins the gear game!

Each app has an online store where you can buy bags, etc. None of them are priced outrageously and I've bought gear from the DoorDash site before. Amazon definitely has some affordable ones as well though.

Now that you're ready to hit the road, let's look at what you'll see.

DoorDash gear

DoorDash used to send you a very small and flimsy bag (mine broke within two weeks) and their red card debit card. At least that's what used to happen but I recently discovered that it no longer sends the bag or card; you have to request it.

Regardless, as I said, I recommend you either find insulated bags in your home or just buy professional ones. My friend who completed the referral got tons of comments from customers about having bags as have I, which have also led to tip increases so they're a no brainer.

They're also a tax write-off so keep the receipt!

You do not have to get those until you know you want to actually continue to deliver for longer than a week but have some sort of bag right away so you can actually do your job. Most households have grocery store ones laying around so start there.

Why the debit cards?

Please be aware that the cards each company sends (or you request) are company cards that have money on it in case you have to pay for an order whether at a restaurant (as is very rarely the case on DoorDash and Grubhub) or a retail/grocery (which work like Instacart shopping orders) order as is the case on DoorDash and UberEats (personally, I don't bother doing those much since Instacart pays better on average).

You will at NO point be required to use your own credit or debit card to make purchases on behalf of the customer, etc.

These cards are pre-loaded with the customer's money for you to swipe at checkout.

Sometimes I get asked if we ever have to use our personal credit/debit cards and that's just never the case. You will not be asked to use your own money ever.

You don't really have to worry about the cards. I've only used the Uber card a couple of times for shop and pay order and I've used the DoorDash card about five times in 2,000+ orders so please don't worry about this too much.

Again, I do Instacart if I wanna shop for customers, not UberEats or DoorDash but if you're planning on shopping on UberEats and DoorDash, just keep these cards handy in your glove box.

App layout 

Let's take a look at how each of the apps compares in terms of layout. This may not seem important but I personally like to have as much information as possible before I go out to deliver.

It's helped me develop some sort of strategy in an otherwise unpredictable industry.

DoorDash app layout

One of the main reasons I chose DoorDash as a backup to Instacart was because the app is similar in its layout.

The layout is clear and has everything you need right on the home screen, including your ratings and earnings. 

That's a major plus for someone who is a visual like me. 

Here's what DoorDash had to say about "earn by time": "You can see the current guaranteed hourly rate for your dash in your app before you start.  While this rate may change throughout the day, once you start your dash, the hourly rate is locked in and will apply to the entire Earn by Time mode dash session.

You can decline or unassign up to one offer every hour. If you decline or unassign more, your Earn by Time dash will automatically end but you’ll still be able to shift to Earn per Offer mode to continue dashing."

Here's the link to the full article on DoorDash.

I don't really see the point of earn by time since there are so many bad orders that I decline quite a few in a row on any given night but like I said, I'll update once I get more experience with the two.

My preliminary opinion on Earn by Time

Earn by Time seems like it's a decent deal at first but with everything on these gig work apps, you have to analyze the reasoning behind it. 

When I signed on to earn by time, I got sent this offer. It gave me the approximate time to complete and the hourly DoorDash earnings. 

I suspect a lot of these Earn by time offers are low/no tip offers that otherwise would get rejected by dashers. 

TBD on that, I'll confirm once I gather the courage to actually complete an hour of earn by time.

I decided to decline and got a notification that I was using my only decline for that hour, another indicator that Earn by time was not to Dashers' benefit. I decided to decline another offer and it kicked me off.

I signed on to Earn per offer and made $35 in the following hour, which was most likely quite a bit more than I would have made if I had taken the Earn by time offer. 

I will actually complete one of these to give you all the details in the coming weeks but I've been around long enough to see when something isn't in my favor on these apps.

I see this as a good opportunity when it's not super busy so you're guaranteed at least that amount per hour but when it's busy, I don't see the point of it quite as much because you might be missing out on higher paying orders since you can see the tip on the Earn per offer orders.

---

Moving on...

The most annoying thing about the DoorDash app is the zones.

Once you're out of the bordered zone (which happens quite often when deliveries take you into another zone), you will not be sent dashes in that new zone and instead, you either have to head back to your zone or end the current dash and start a new one in that zone.

DoorDash has a new feature called Dash Along the Way but it still doesn't provide that zone free felling that UberEats has. Dash Along the way is an improvement but it'd be better if DoorDash did away with zones altogether.

---

UberEats app layout

As I said before, UberEats seems to share the app with the Uber drivers so the layout is slightly more confusing at first.

UberEats FINALLY changed the fact that you couldn't zoom in on the map. Now you're able to zoom in on that second restaurant for double orders. UberEats still doesn't give you the name of both restaurants so it's still a guessing game and much clunkier than on DoorDash or Grubhub,

It's obviously not a good idea to zoom do while driving but if you're sitting in your car waiting for an order, at least you're able to zoom in to see that second restaurant and if it's a slow one if you've been burned by it before. More on that later.

---

Grubhub app layout

As I said before, Grubhub is a bit more serious (read: not as fun to use). Grubhub just changed its app layout slightly so you can now access the map and slide to available in a couple of steps, which used to be quite a few steps before.

The app is still super clunky so while it's an improvement, it still needs work. It finally did away with the clunky menu and everything is now on the bottom similar to DoorDash. 

The map still sucks overall and going online is still a little clunky as well.

---

You'll be shown a screen reading "Ready to deliver?" with a slider to go from "Unavailable" to "Taking offers". 

---

Once you slide it to "Taking offers", you'll be sent orders.

You can immediately slide it back to "Unavailable" so do not worry about being on the hook for an order right away.

While you're not on the hook for orders if you're not scheduled, Grubhub seems to encourage scheduling blocks and it seems like you're bound by those although my first few times, I couldn't schedule a block because they were all taken for over a week. You'll want to schedule blocks if you plan on doing Grubhub long-term since you'll be able move up on their program levels.

Once I scheduled a block, Grubhub messaged me to make sure I knew I was scheduled. You can still go out without scheduling a block and I received plenty of orders the times I went out without scheduling. It's my preferred way of delivering since I don't like to be bound by schedules hence why I do gig work.

The Grubhub zone map with hotspots leaves much to be desired since you can not tell where anything and getting on the road means jumping through the task screen.

As I said before, I love having everything on one screen so Grubhub is definitely my least favorite layout.

Aside from the zone drawback, DoorDash wins overall layout and accessibility with UberEats behind it and Grubhub coming in dead last.

Declining, accepting and dropping an order

Yes I'll start with declining because you are most likely not going to accept the first order that is sent to you unless it's a good order. This is generally true whether it's your first ever delivery or your 1,000th; the first order that pops up is rarely the one you'll accept since it's most likely a reject from other drivers.

Let's take a look at each app in more detail!

DoorDash orders

---

UberEats orders

UberEats gives you the approximate time it'll take and the distance, which are generally pretty accurate. The distance means where you're currently are to the restaurant to the customer(s)'. It doesn't show you the exact location of the customer(s), just an approximate cross street. 

You either hit accept request or decline by hitting the X on the right hand side.

I definitely like that UberEats shows how long it will take to complete. It's just unfortunate it doesn't give both restaurants and a more accurate map to show the customers areas so I can see exactly where I'm going like on DoorDash and in part, Grubhub.

Each app has double orders, where two customer orders are grouped either at the same restaurant or a different one. This is no problem on Grubhub or DoorDash since you can see both restaurants, which can be helpful if you know one restaurant isn't as speedy as the other. 

Both DoorDash and Grubhub let you zoom in on the almost exact location of the customer(s) and restaurant(s), which is super helpful if you're more visual and aren't good at knowing all the street names in your state!

The UberEats app has improved but it's not as clean as it could be. It remains a huge drawback on UberEats. At least for me.

---

Grubhub orders

Grubhub's accept / reject buttons are pretty straightforward with a smaller "Reject offer" button that's quite hard to select, especially if an order pops up while driving.

Grubhub shows you a map of where you'll end up and you can zoom in on both the restaurant and customer locations. It also gives you the mileage from where you currently are to the restaurant to the customer(s). 

---

So that was the basic layout for each app. This should help you get a feel for what to expect.

In my opinion, DoorDash wins in terms of the details it gives you upfront to make an informed decision about whether an order will be lucrative enough for you to take it.

Grubhub is a close second since you can zoom in on the map and it gives you all the details about which restaurants for double orders.

UberEats remains my least favorite in this category because I like to know where I'm going and what restaurants I'll be popping in to for double orders.

I have a good idea of ​​how long restaurants in my area take so with UberEats withholding the name of the second restaurant, I am often in for a rude surprise. I will say that you can drop an order if there's a long wait-time and you already have another customer's order waiting in the car. 

Accepting an order and delivery

As shown above in the declining an order examples, you just click "Accept" on DoorDash, "Accept offer" on Grubhub and "Accept request" on UberEats.

You'll then head to the restaurant and follow the in-app instructions. If you have a double order, you'll just have to pay even closer attention for items like drinks, etc.

Other than that, double or triple orders are similar to single orders.

Again, DoorDash has the cleanest interface with all the info you need to do your job. You just click "Confirm" and follow delivery instructions.

Grubhub is almost too detailed with info about when the customer (called "diner" on Grubhub) placed the order, etc. You also have to say you've arrived at the store, you picked up the order and you're getting on the road to deliver, (Leaving) which is a bit much and falls in line with my overall impression that Grubhub is quite serious about the delivery game.

You still do not know the customer's address once you accept an order on UberEats so again, you don't really know the whole route ahead of time. whereas you do on DoorDash and Grubhub. 

UberEats just changed its buttons so I've updated this page, It is now to confirm pickup, which then defaults to their terrible navigation (hint: Always use another navigation system like Google Maps, not Uber's, it's terrible).

Just follow the customer's delivery instructions and you're all done. This part is relatively straightforward on all of them with some weird options like "wait in car" on UberEats.

Other than that, it's a relatively straightforward process, one you'll get better at over time. Customer's delivery instructions often leave much to be desired but like I said, you'll nail this over time. 

Dropping an order

In case the restaurant informs you of a long wait time (15-20 minutes is too long for me unless it's a $ 20+ order), you should consider dropping the order because you have to think about the bottom line (not to sound greedy but this took me a while to learn that I do not get bonus points for waiting).

I meet so many new delivery drivers who are waiting at the restaurant for 20+ minutes and that's just not profitable, please drop the order, the customer will be OK since another driver can just pick up the order.

Dropping an order on DoorDash

I briefly touched on that before but dropping an order on DoorDash is easy but it does count against your completion rate.

If your completion rate drops below 80%, DoorDash may deactivate your account.

Still, it's no biggie to drop an order on occasion since your completion rate goes up again once you complete orders.

To drop an order you've accepted, just go to the? icon on the upper right hand corner. 

Follow the "Can't do this order" steps. I usually choose "Order not ready".

Hint: if you accepted an order but the store/restaurant is closed when you arrive (it's happened to me a couple of times), you want to get on Chat support and report it, you'll get compensated for it so you always wanna report a closed store via chat. 

But that's it, dropping an order is pretty easy on DoorDash. Once you drop the order, you'll be taken back to the home screen where new orders will pop up. 

Dropping an order on UberEats

You'll be directed back to the main screen for new orders to pop up.

Unlike DoorDash, UberEats does not really have a good chat function if your issue is bigger than just dropping the order, which can be annoying but it's also no big deal.

I've only had to call Uber support once and it was fine. 

---

Dropping an order on Grubhub

To drop an order on Grubhub can seem daunting since they make it seem like you have to call support or get on chat (Care) but I recently talked to a person who's been doing Grubhub for a while and he showed me how to circumvent having to call Grubhub Care to drop an order by selecting either "Total payment is too low" or "Distance is too far".

 But first, you have to select "There's a problem" from the bottom of the screen.

Now select "I can't deliver this order". 

Finally, walk through the steps to select "Total payment is too low" or "Distance is too far" as a reason even if the reason is something else.

Everything other than those two options will result in you having to call support to drop the order. I think Grubhub is going to change that but the last time I used it, I had a wait time of 60 minutes and had to select pay too low to drop the order without having to talk to Grubhub Care on the phone.

Once you go through those steps, Grubhub will ask you to confirm that you indeed want to drop the order (reject offer) and then it'll take you back to the home screen where new offers will pop up.

Grubhub can be a bit of a pain when it comes to restaurant wait times, especially if your strategy is to park outside of popular restaurants so you walk right in.

I've talked to a few buddies some of the restaurants and they said that Grubhub sends a driver a few minutes after the order gets placed to ensure timely delivery but it leads to the driver having to wait quite a bit each time.

I've experienced this myself. Pretty much every Grubhub order I took had a wait time, one restaurant said 60 minutes, which is the above order I dropped. 

Many of us park near restaurants we know are busy so that strategy doesn't work quite as well with Grubhub.

DoorDash and UberEats win for simplicity of being able to drop an order. Grubhub again lags behind in terms of ease of use within the app.

However, Grubhub does have advantages in one big category and that is base pay that includes mileage. 

Retail orders and card orders

Each app has retail orders where you pick up from a place that's not a restaurant. Places like Walmart, Petsmart or Gamestop.

I only do the occasional Petsmart or Walmart pickup but rarely a shopping order. I stick to picking up restaurant orders since that's kind of what I signed up for and the process is smooth for the most part.

If I want to shop, I'll do Instacart since its app is quite a bit better when it comes to scanning items compared to DoorDash and especially UberEats.

As always, you'll have to see if an order is worth your while before you accept it.

Restaurant card orders on DoorDash and Grubhub

Just note that some restaurants require you to pay by card but you'll see it upfront on DoorDash (it'll clearly say Red Card order) and Grubhub so you don't really have to worry about it. If you don't have your DoorDash red card or Grubhub corporate card with you, just decline the order when it pops up or drop it if you realize you don't have your card with you.

These card pickup orders are rare so it's really not something to worry about. Again, these are company cards you're sent when you sign up and at no point require you to use your own money, they are preloaded with the customer's money.

I've only had about five orders like that in 1,000 DoorDash orders so just keep the card they send you in your car at all times but don't worry too much about it.

I have videos on my YouTube (your gig economist) that show you how to deliver orders and all that good stuff but again, I don't wanna fill up this page with too much crap. 

Ratings

I will give you a brief summary of how ratings work on each app.

On DoorDash, customers select a rating between 1 and 5 for your delivery. The feedback includes Communication, Order Handling, Friendliness and Followed Delivery Instructions. This is the most detailed ratings system and is reminiscent of Instacart.

UberEats has a thumbs up and down rating, which is really annoying because it's easier just to thumbs down than it is to think about a rating between 1-5.

It took almost 500 orders on DoorDash for me to receive anything other than a 5-star rating and equally as many orders on Instacart.

However, within my first week on UberEats, a customer who selected "meet at door" as delivery option and wasn't there so I texted her and once I did not hear back rang the doorbell (a perfectly fine option for when the customer selects "meet at door"). She must have fallen asleep so she gave me a thumbs down even though I quite literally followed delivery instructions.

Surprisingly, Grubhub does not have ratings for its drivers. For a delivery service that is so detailed about each step I take, it's really surprising that there are no ratings. 

I'm not sure how I feel about not having ratings because I like customer feedback. It's made me better at this job. 

Intro promotions 

Please note that the intro promos will probably differ based on when you sign up as they change all the time based on weather, demand and other factors.

Each app except for Grubhub had a one week promotion (for your very first week only), where you could earn extra cash on top of your earnings for completing x amount of deliveries. 

For DoorDash, it was "get an extra $ 75 for completing 35 orders", which was quite easy to complete and the $ 75 showed up as earnings right after completion.

UberEats had a great intro promotion at the time I signed up with "complete 40 orders, get an extra $ 200". Yes, an extra $ 200 on top of all the earnings from the 40 orders!

I was unable to complete the 40 orders but I did complete 20 orders for an extra $ 100, which was also a good deal but I will say that I did not receive enough orders that week to take me to 40 orders. Not by a long shot so it felt like the $ 200 was a bit of a dangling carrot I was never gonna get.

Grubhub did not have any promotions when I first signed up. That does not mean it does not have a lot to offer in the earnings category though.

As you may recall, I described Grubhub as a bit serious and the earnings category is where that comes in handy. I recently got a complete 6 orders, get an extra $21 offer but it came with the caveat of having a 100% acceptance rate, meaning accepting every order that came to me. I didn't do that.

I absolutely love the no condition "make an extra X amount for doing X amount of deliveries" but I despise conditions like the one Grubhub had. Why would I essentially be forced to take a series of smaller orders just to make an extra $21 when I can just wait for bigger orders that would exceed those $21? Silly. 

I think Grubhub has intro promotions like UberEats and DoorDash but it just didn't have them at the time I signed up.

Therefore, UberEats and DoorDash win in the intro promotion category.

Referrals

As I said in the beginning, I had a friend finish a referral, which made me $600 and her $400 plus the earnings she made on DoorDash during that time.

The referrals I've seen on DoorDash are higher than on UberEats. Grubhub doesn't really have them or at least I haven't encountered them. 

I was able to track my referral's progress throughout.

Once she was done, the $600 showed up on DoorDash right away. Her $400 showed up on her account right away as well.

UberEats, Grubhub and DoorDash Earnings

Yes I know, you've been waiting to hear all about  UberEats, Grubhub and DoorDash pay info.

 I will give you all the details in just a moment. I do want to say that the gig economy and as such food delivery is entirely based on demand.

A year ago, I was able to make $400 a week on DoorDash super easily and this year, I struggled to make just $200. You should have a backup plan and app in case demand is down for one.

OK, here's the good stuff. You may have heard that one app pays more than the other. A lot of drivers say UberEats pays more but that's not the case at all. And I'll show you in a sec.

Yes, you can make decent money on UberEats but that money will come from customer tips, not UberEats just like all the other gig work apps.

UberEats base pay and earnings

You'll see plenty of orders come your way on UberEats that look like this.

---

DoorDash base pay and earnings

Here's a similar DoorDash order

---

DoorDash, Grubhub and UberEats earnings in comparison

Yes, the base-pay on UberEats, Grubhub and DoorDash is really only around $2-$3 per order (and that's before gas and taxes) so it's absolutely essential that you take higher tip orders.

Grubhub again says it pays about 34 cents per mile but that really only starts adding up above 10 miles and that's already kind of a far distance.

It usually pays to stay in a smaller radius unless you really know the area you end up in.

UberEats pay 

Here's another UberEats pay example. I want to keep things super realistic for you all. So here's an order that didn't pay quite as much and I had to wait at the restaurant for ten minutes, which I normally don't do but the delivery distance was low and it kept me in a good area in terms of restaurants. 

You can see the base-pay on UberEats at $2.15.

As you can see, each trip earns points. I usually only aim for gold. UberEats doesn't require you to accept a bunch of low paying orders to reach different levels, which is a big plus. It's just based on how many orders you complete in a month. 

DoorDash pay 

DoorDash just recently added the tip increase feature where customers can increase their tip. I've gotten one $2 increase but I will update this page should the tip increases roll in more.

---

Grubhub pay

Here is an order I took on Grubhub because it was quite decent. I didn't have to wait long at the restaurant, which was a little unusual so the order took just under 30 minutes.

---

---

As I said, on its website Grubhub pays 34 cents (it used to be over 50 cents) per mile but not much more in terms of base-pay. Grubhub only pays slightly more due to the mileage but this becomes problematic when the mileage is only 1 or 2 miles in which case you'll also see less $ on Grubhub if the customer doesn't tip much as you can see in this example.

What if it is a low mileage order on Grubhub?

I hope showing you these real life numbers give you an idea of what to look out for to really make decent money. 

Important reminders to maximize your earnings on DoorDash, UberEats and Grubhub

How many orders per hour is normal? And how much can I expect to make weekly?

You can do 2-3 orders an hour on UberEats and DoorDash, the wait times on Grubhub can be high so you might just be able to do 1-2 per hour. You can see how important it is to take higher tipping orders and nothing with crazy far delivery distances. 

You should aim to make an average of $35 an hour. This doesn't mean every hour but some hours I'm able to make $50 and then the next hour maybe just $20 but it usually averages to $35 before gas and taxes. You may see more in metropolitan areas and less in more rural areas but always make sure you consider that all of this is before gas and taxes so be smart about the orders you take and don't aim for things like Platinum levels if it doesn't make sense.

This summer was really bad for me and there were very few orders. I didn't force myself to go out because it was just such a drag, which is the downside of gig work. The constant dependance on demand can make it quite tough, especially if you rely on it full-time.

How much you'll make is essentially up to you and on demand obviously.

When demand is up, I am strategic and only go out for lunch and dinner orders 5-6 days a week. That allows me to make between $ 400-600 weekly plus whatever I make on Instacart (another $400+).

Some of the drivers I've talked to go out late at night but I can barely find customer's homes during the day so that's a no for me. I talked to an UberEats guy the other day and he said he's able to make about $ 1,000 a week by going out late on weekends (4 PM-11PM). He also does Instacart.

I generally stick to doing Instacart during the day and DoorDash, UberEats or Grubhub in the evenings, usually from 5PM-8PM. Demand has been down so I don't go out every night, just close to the weekend like Thursday-Sunday.

So you see, many of us make this a full-time gig by working on different apps and how much you earn depends on where you live, availability of orders and a combination of strategy and hustle.

Let me briefly mention the cash out process in case you've missed it in the beginning of this article.

Each app allows you to cash out your earnings as you make them.

If you're super strapped for cash and need money right after your background check clears, UberEats is the way to go. The bank verification takes virtually no time and for 50 cents you can cash out the moment you make money.

DoorDash takes up to two weeks for you to use the cash out function, Grubhub only takes a couple of days. I know this is important to some of you so I wanted to mention it twice.

DoorDash now has DasherDirect, which eliminates the cashout fees but you have to use their bank or just wait for the weekly transfer, which is always free on all apps.

You have to be a dasher to sign up for DasherDirect. I talk about that here if you're interested in some of the pros I've encountered using DasherDirect over the last few months.

Decision Time! DoorDash or UberEats or Grubhub?

DoorDash's rewards system is not even worth going into detail here because it requires you to keep your acceptance rate at 70% (or 50% if you're just going for Silver) and in my opinion is not a real reward.

If you look closely, the Gold and Platinum tiers have that same 70% acceptance rate as Top Dasher had before so it's the same nonsense just disguised as tier levels.

Personally, I never went for Top Dasher because of that 70% acceptance rate so I doubt I'll go for the Gold or Platinum here.

I would have to take $2 orders on a regular basis, which I simply can't afford, literally.

I talk more about whether Top Dasher and its new tier system is worth it, here.

Mathematically it makes no sense to strive for it in my area because some of the orders are around $ 3. That's crazy low so you'd have to accept crazy low orders for a month just to maybe get higher paying orders once you reach a level. 

Think about it, delivery services like DoorDash depend on delivery speed so you really think they're gonna wait for a Platinum Dasher to drive across town when you're sitting in front of that restaurant ready to go? Absolutely not.

I've had my acceptance rate reset to 100% on DoorDash and saw no difference in orders. I still got no tip orders so don't fall for it unless you can really swing it with good orders. 

No way, I usually decline 5-10 orders just to get a good DoorDash order so I keep my acceptance rate really low.  

Grubhub has program levels as part of their driver recognition program. The levels are based on your acceptance rate, attendance rate, and block drop rate. You can read more about that on Grubhub's website, here.

Again, to me that's restrictive but because Grubhub has higher paying orders, I usually accept more orders rather than declining them like I have to do on DoorDash. UberEats has some incredibly high paying orders but the grouping of orders where you can't see the second restaurant really messes with my strategy.

Personally, I do not like to be bogged down by schedules, which is why I'm in this industry so I'm OK leaving some money behind in favor of freedom to drop an order if I want to without getting dinged. I also like to start or end my day whenever I want, depending on demand of course.

So if you're looking for that freedom of just hitting the road right away, DoorDash and UberEats are your best bet.

UberEats also allows or even encourages customers to increase their tip (yes customers can also decrease their tip, which has only happened to me once) so I've had some crazy tip increases (I'm talking $10-$15 extra) for speedy delivery and for having insulated bags that kept the food hot. 

DoorDash only recently added a tip increase option and I've gotten a couple but nothing as crazy as on UberEats.

Grubhub has a tip increase option but honestly, it's not as straightforward as UberEats' so I don't even consider it a pro, I've since removed it from the pros and cons table as a pro because like the Grubhub app, it's not a straightforward process like it is on UberEats.

If you are willing to sacrifice some of that freedom for slightly higher base pay (unless the mileage is low) and an annoying app interface, then Grubhub is your choice. Grubhub also has catering orders (so does DoorDash in some areas but you have to deliver at least 200 orders and have decent stats), which are reserved for higher levels and I've not gotten there yet nor had any of the drivers I talked to. 

Grubhub in general takes care of its drivers by sending new orders while you're out delivering another so you technically have an order in line while you're still out on your current order. 

You can of course decline that order if it's crappy but I've done well when getting good orders sent to me while I was out delivering.

UberEats and DoorDash do this to an extent but Grubhub is very consistent about it.

This brings me to new con on UberEats. UberEats will send you a new order when you're delivering at a customer's house. That's super annoying because you can be hitting the delivered button and at that moment you actually accept a new (probably crappy) order. I've had to cancel so many orders because I accidentally accepted them that I'm now making it a con on this list.

---

Here's a quick summary of what I deem pros and cons of each app. I know they're subjective but it'll give you an overview of what I discussed above.

*As a dasher, you can now sign up for the DasherDirect debit card that circumvents the cash out fee. Read more about that in the "You might like" pages at the bottom

UberEats now also has a card that's similar but I haven't checked it out personally.

---

*Varies by region and season

---

You might like

If you'd rather become an Instacart shopper in addition to any of these apps we discussed here, see my comparison of DoorDash vs. Instacart, here. 

Here are the basics of getting started with each: DoorDash, UberEats or Grubhub.

And for Instacart, here.

To read if the DasherDirect debit card is right for you once you're a dasher, go here.

Follow me on Instagram

Subscribe to my YouTube channel 

Back to top

© Your Gigeconomist. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy